Siobhan Magnus was a blast with "Paint It Black". I think it was the best performance of the night where almost all of them bored my brains out. It was a good risk but it brought out the best in her.
Of course, the judges were ecstatic to hear that over-the-top performance. Randy thought she brought the drama back into the competition. Ellen loved the way she looked and the Siobhan Magnus sounded her best. Kara was reminded of Adam Lambert last year - with the drama and stairs. Simon Cowell agreed to all them and wanted to hear some more screaming in her next performances. Watch Siobhan Magnus "Paint It Black" American Idol Top 12 March 16 performance: